Posted by Roger Hergenrader on December 29, 1997 at 15:13:02:
In Reply to: Radial Arm or Table Saw posted by Bill Slifko on November 03, 1997 at 16:36:44:
: I would like to buy a good saw for all around home
: use. Problem is I don't know whether a Radial Arm
: Saw or a Table Saw would be the best choice. Could
: anyone who has worked with both advise me? I was
: under the impression that pulling the saw over the
: work would be safer than pushing the work over the
: saw. Also if possible please advise me regarding
: a good brand name of saw.
: Thanks, wslifko@imap.pitt.edu
Bill:
As you can see by the previous responses, there is no clear-cut asnwer. Each of us has a preference or preferences. I too have both saws, they each have a place in my shop for specific work.
When ripping long and wide boards, the tabel saw is the tool. However, one can just as easily use a straight edge and a hand held circular saw. No matter which is used, if you plan on joining boards, you will have to use a plane or jointer. The edges are not sufficiently true so that a near invisible edge is obtained by any other method.
A table saw with a poor fence is a lesson in frustration. Also, Safety; one needs a work surface large enough to support your wood or by using portable stands.
Normally, a 10" radial arm saw can rip cut a board 24" wide, crosscutting is somewhat less. Table saws have a much broader range.
If you have a distributor near you or if you can attend any of the woodworking shows, I'd suggest that you make a point of visiting one or both. Look at the equipment, see for youself what is involved with aligning the different models.
ALL saws/equipment need to be routinely checked for alignment and they will need some adjustment. Also, cheap stamped blades are not necessarily flat. You might find them as much as +/-.040" or more out.
Certainly cost is involved with any decision you make. Speaking from experience as most of us do, the old adage of "You get what you pay for" is true. A good tool will last a long time and you will not only be happy with it, you will use it and be thrilled with the products you produce.
After all of these responses,the bottom line is that the decission is yours to make. One more thing, you might check the "For Sale" portion of you newspaper. Many times you can obtain very good used equipment for less money than new would cost. Another source of information is a local woodworking club or a highschool shop instructor.
Good Luck